Casamento's Restaurant

Casamento's Restaurant

Damn Good
Book a Table
Review
About
My Take
Our Take

Casamento's has been shucking oysters on Magazine Street for more than a century, and the place still runs like it hasn't noticed the calendar turning. The tiled room, the short menu, the insistence on closing for the months when Gulf oysters aren't right — none of it has bent to modern restaurant logic, and that stubbornness is the whole point.

The fried oyster loaf is the reason to come. It's a dense, griddled-bread sandwich stacked with oysters fried hot and fast, the kind of dish that makes you understand why people have been ordering it for generations instead of trying something new. Soft shell crab earns its spot on the table when it's in season. This is not a place chasing range — it's a place that picked a handful of things a long time ago and refused to let them slip.

The wait can run long and the room doesn't pretend to be anything other than what it is, which occasionally reads as indifference to newcomers expecting polish. That's a fair trade for food this honest. Multiple recognition lists have singled it out over the years, which only confirms what the oyster loaf already proves on its own.

Go hungry, go when oysters are in season, and don't ask for substitutions.

The Spot
Casamento's has been shucking oysters on Magazine Street for more than a century. It was founded by Joe Casamento, an Italian immigrant from Ustica, and is still family-run, currently co-owned by CJ Gerdes, the founder's grandson. The restaurant is built as a neighborhood seafood spot centered on a counter oyster bar, and it closes for the stretch each year when Gulf oysters are out of season.

The oyster loaf is the signature dish — raw or fried oysters stacked into a sandwich, served with homemade French fries. The rest of the menu runs through a Fried Oyster Loaf and Soft Shell Crab Loaf, Seafood Gumbo, Oyster Stew, charbroiled oysters on the half shell, raw oysters on the half shell, and a Big Easy Platter billed as a full New Orleans seafood feast. The fried seafood is gluten-free, and the oysters are locally sourced and shucked to order.

Casamento's has developed a serious following as a long-running fixture of the city's oyster culture, a reputation that has held across generations on Magazine Street.
THE FACTS
Damn Good
RATINGS4.4 stars across 581 reviews2 sources
The Regulars
Been? Settle it.
No regular has weighed in yet. Agree, argue, set us straight.
Your Rating
City

New Orleans

Neighborhood

Uptown

Price

$$

Cuisine

American

Chef

Owner