The menu extends well past the pizza. Jumbo Limoncello Chicken Wings and a Rotolo Pizza Roll stuffed with pesto and salami open things, house specials run to Meat Lasagna and Eggplant Rollatini, and the OG Pizzeria Salad loads up on olives and pepperoncini. A Nutella- and powdered sugar-topped dessert pizza has become one of the kitchen's known items, alongside a broader run of house-made desserts.
The Michelin Guide has selected Marco's Coal-Fired in both its 2025 and 2026 editions. Regulars point to the food, value, and atmosphere as the draw, though other accounts describe service and delivery as inconsistent.

