Dishes that keep coming up include the goat itself, pig face, chickpea fritters, pork shank, shishito peppers, hamachi crudo, and halibut, alongside bread and a well-known mousse. Short ribs, salad, and ice cream round things out for those wanting lighter or sweeter options.
Izard won the James Beard Foundation's Best Chef award in 2013, following a finalist nod in 2012, and the restaurant was a finalist for Best New Restaurant in 2011. Girl & The Goat has held a Michelin Bib Gourmand every year from 2019 through 2025.

