The menu changes daily based on what local farmers, fishermen, and foragers deliver, with recurring dishes like wood oven roasted Maine rope-cultured mussels, wood-grilled hanger steak, and turnspit-roasted half chicken, alongside a rotating raw bar and a house-made charcuterie program.
Chef-partner Sam Hayward built the restaurant's reputation and was named Best Chef Northeast by the James Beard Foundation in 2004; Frederic Eliot now runs the kitchen as executive chef. Fore Street has been named a James Beard Foundation Outstanding Restaurant semifinalist across numerous years, and Hayward himself was recognized as an Outstanding Chef semifinalist. The restaurant is part of a small Portland family that also includes Street & Company, Scales, and Standard Baking Company.

