Dino's Tomato Pie sits at 1524 E Olive Way in Capitol Hill, a 21-and-over spot built around the New Jersey tomato pie style its owner grew up eating at joints like Kinchley's — pizza with the sauce laid over the cheese rather than under it. That format anchors the menu here, offered in both round and square versions.
Beyond the pies, the menu runs garlic knots, a Jersey salad, calzones, and brownies or blondies for dessert. The bar side leans into real cocktails, including watermelon negronis on tap, and the room has built a reputation for its atmosphere as much as for what comes out of the kitchen — regulars point to good value and an authentic feel as reasons they keep coming back.
The Infatuation scored Dino's Tomato Pie 8.7 out of 10.
Beyond the pies, the menu runs garlic knots, a Jersey salad, calzones, and brownies or blondies for dessert. The bar side leans into real cocktails, including watermelon negronis on tap, and the room has built a reputation for its atmosphere as much as for what comes out of the kitchen — regulars point to good value and an authentic feel as reasons they keep coming back.
The Infatuation scored Dino's Tomato Pie 8.7 out of 10.