Paulie Gee's Slice Shop sits on South 13th Street as part of a multi-city Paulie Gee's operation, serving traditional New York-style pizza by the slice and whole pie, in both round and square formats. The upside-down Sicilian-style pies stand out, including the Freddy Prinze and the Hellboy, a pepperoni pie finished with Mike's Hot Honey. A full vegan lineup runs alongside the regular menu, built with Numu vegan mozzarella and Follow Your Heart vegan parmesan on pies like the Vegan Freddy Prinze.
The room doubles as a hangout as much as a pizzeria: a pool table, a curated selection of 70s and 80s vinyl for sale, and a full bar fill out the space. Dessert leans into old-school slice shop tradition, with L&B Spumoni Gardens spumoni ices and lemon ices on the menu. Regulars have noted the retro atmosphere and the shop's late-night draw on weekends.
The room doubles as a hangout as much as a pizzeria: a pool table, a curated selection of 70s and 80s vinyl for sale, and a full bar fill out the space. Dessert leans into old-school slice shop tradition, with L&B Spumoni Gardens spumoni ices and lemon ices on the menu. Regulars have noted the retro atmosphere and the shop's late-night draw on weekends.