Mordecai

Mordecai

Damn Good
Book a Table
Review
About
My Take
Our Take

Mordecai sits across the street from Wrigley Field and could easily coast on that address alone, serving overpriced bar food to a captive crowd. It doesn't. The menu reads like a kitchen actually trying: mussels, duck gnocchi, a vegetable tagine sitting next to two distinct burger builds, none of it phoned in for the foot traffic.

The smart move is treating game days as an event rather than an inconvenience. When the Cubs are playing, the happy hour stretches the length of the game, and arancini and beer-battered cheese curds at a discount are exactly the food you want in your hand watching a broadcast from the bar. It's a neighborhood restaurant that understood its neighborhood and built the right menu around it, then bothered to make the food good anyway.

A recent interior overhaul and menu reset could have gone generic. It didn't dilute the identity — this is still confident American cooking with real technique behind the comfort-food surface. Three Michelin selections across separate years, plus a spot on a national list, back up what the room already tells you: this is a Wrigleyville restaurant with standards higher than its location requires.

The Spot
Mordecai sits on Clark Street in Wrigleyville, just steps from Wrigley Field, though it's built as a neighborhood restaurant rather than a stadium stop. Chef Matthias Merges works from a seasonal, local-ingredient approach, turning out traditional American dishes with a sense of whimsy rather than strict formality.

The name comes from Mordecai "Three Finger" Brown, the Cubs pitcher whose unconventional curveball — a byproduct of a childhood farm injury — made him one of the era's most dominant arms, and whose 1908 standoff with mob threats before a pennant-deciding start against the Giants gives the restaurant its backstory.

The bar carries an extensive list of vintage and collectible spirits alongside a cocktail program curated by the same team behind Logan Square's Billy Sunday, making it as much a destination as the dining room itself.

Mordecai has been selected for the Chicago Michelin Guide in 2019, 2021, and 2023.
THE FACTS
Damn Good
AWARDMichelin Guide Selected2019–2023
RATINGS4.4 stars across 357 reviews2 sources
The Regulars
Been? Settle it.
No regular has weighed in yet. Agree, argue, set us straight.
Your Rating
City

Chicago

Neighborhood

Wrigleyville

Price

$$$

Cuisine

American

Chef

Owner