Acme Oyster House

Acme Oyster House

Review
About
My Take
Our Take

Acme has been shucking on Iberville since 1910, and the chargrilled oyster — garlic butter, parmesan, a run under the flame — is a real invention that half the Quarter now imitates.

The oysters are fine. Fine is what fourteen thousand reviews average out to when the visitors love a place and the regulars quit coming, and it is the most damning word available in this city. No critic, guide, or award has ever argued otherwise. An hour in that line buys the median oyster in America's best eating city. Spend it anywhere else.

The Spot
Acme Oyster House serves the raw-bar and Creole menu built around chargrilled oysters and oyster shooters, alongside po-boys, red beans and rice, étouffée, soft-shell crab, and gumbo. The raw bar is the draw: the restaurant reports shucking more than a million oysters a year.

It pulls a heavy mix of tourists and regulars, and opinions on it run in two directions. Some reviewers call the food and service great and say it's worth the wait; others describe inconsistent service, rude staff encounters, and oyster freshness that varies visit to visit. The volume the place does seems to be part of both stories.
THE TELLS
Nope
CROWDS14,031 reviews — top 1% in the city
RATING4.6 stars, and we don't buy it
LOCALSCalled a tourist trap, repeatedly2026
SPLITVisitors love it. Regulars don't go.2026
The Regulars
Think we got it wrong?
No regular has made the case yet. Be the first — agree, argue, set us straight.
Your Rating
City

New Orleans

Neighborhood

Central Business District

Price

$$

Cuisine

Seafood

Chef

Owner