The menu runs classic Irish dishes alongside contemporary plates, including wood-fired pizza. Bangers and Mash, Fish and Chips, Irish Stew, and Irish Chicken Curry sit on the menu next to an Irish Breakfast and a Smash Burger. The kitchen is known for its Seafood Chowder and Spice Bag, and a Sunday Roast — roast beef, turkey, and ham with all the trimmings — runs weekly.
McGonagle's was included on The New York Times' Restaurant List in 2025.

