Seafood
Nine seafood spots clear our bar in Naples. Four are Damn Good, the rest worth a visit.
Sails, The Syren, The Turtle Club, and Wickies Lighthouse lead the Damn Good tier, spread from Old Naples to Sanibel. The rest sit at Worth Trying, from BALEEN's $$$$ North Naples room down to $$ spots like Island Gypsy Cafe and Mr.Big Fish. No stars or medals here — just a solid stretch across price points and neighborhoods worth working through.
The spots in this guide
9 places in Naples, ranked by how good they actually are.
- 1Sails RestaurantOld Naples · SeafoodDamn Good
- 2Wickies Lighthouse RestaurantSanibel · SeafoodDamn Good
- 3The Turtle ClubNorth Naples · SeafoodDamn Good
- 4The Syren Oyster & Cocktail BarOld Naples · SeafoodDamn Good
- 5The Claw BarOld Naples · SeafoodWorth Trying
- 6USS Nemo RestaurantPark Shore · SeafoodWorth Trying
- 7BALEENNorth Naples · SeafoodWorth Trying
- 8Island Gypsy Cafe & Marina BarMarco Island · SeafoodWorth Trying
- 9Mr.Big FishPark Shore · SeafoodWorth Trying