This is the list people ask about. Five restaurants that have held their standard long enough and consistently enough that there's no asterisk next to any of them. Bastion doesn't have a fixed menu and doesn't need one — the kitchen operates at a level where the constraints other restaurants rely on just don't apply. The Catbird Seat is one of the best dining experiences in the country, full stop. Locust punches at a weight class most of Nashville doesn't know exists. Peninsula is the most ambitious restaurant in East Nashville and one of the five best restaurants in the city — Chef Jake Howell is building something that belongs in any national conversation about serious American cooking. Kisser is the newest addition and already belongs. Getting on this list requires more than a few good months. Staying on it requires everything.